Can anyone help Id please

[scottnokes]

Hi everyone. I'm new to the forum and collecting arrowheads and I got these at a antique shop for a dollar each. What I want to find out are they real. The little one seems very weird shape in its profile when I look at edge ways on compared to a real Robinson point arrowhead I have. Thanks for any help fellow collectors. Scott

[gregszybala]

Look legit Scott. Some arrowheads are just ugly. What area of the country are you in?

[scottnokes]

Hi there gregz. Im in southern Illinois but I got them in cape girardeu at a antique mall, Missouri. So I assume they were found around there on a farm. Its about 89 miles south of St Louis

[Scorpion68]

Hey Scott - Agree with Greg. Some I have I thought were broken but turns out they were whole. Sometimes the point was worked on one edge which caused them to look retarded but they're authentic. By the By - if you're from North Carolina - they have a Edgefield Scraper that is somewhat similar to what you have.

Maybe not as ugly as your's but close, Huh? And also found these




The Albany Knife is from the South Central area and the full page Edgefield Scraper is from Florida.

[scottnokes]

Thanks so much for the photos. Thai is a great help. Which books are they

[Hoss]

Those pictures are from Overstreets Identification Guide 14th edition. http://stores.arrowheads.com/detail.php?pid=MzExOTU%3D

[willjo]

That piece does look like an Edgefield Scraper, Texas has something similar and it is called an Albany knife

[Von]

They look real to me. Nice pick up for a buck each!

Von

[CoachG]

Welcome to the site.

[JoshinMO]

Hemphill and Etley maybe.

[scottnokes]

Thank you everyone for your time and kindness. Does anyone know why the little one is so small and what time period these would be roughly
Thanks

[JoshinMO]

Little one is exhausted/used up, they are mid/late archaic.

[p kurt]

The broken stemmed point looks like a buck creek to me, which is a late archaic piece. That side notch looks like a super used up big Sandy variant.

[scottnokes]

So does everyone agree i got 2 real Arrowheads. For $ each. In they case, I love them again now I know there real. Is the general consensus they Are mid to Late archaic
Thanks everyone. You are all awesome
You have Made a new collector enthusiastic Again because I thought I got ripped of with repos or fakes