I just read the permanent post by Painshill about fake catlinite pipes. Sounds like it is very difficult to determine authentic from modern reproduction. But can anyone give more specifics?
Obviously, modern tool marks is a give away, as is a clean bowl interior.
But what about exterior patina: is there 'old' patina to look for? Deep, deep red Catlinite color?
What about 'wear' - should there be wear on an old, authentic stone pipe?
And what constitutes 'authentic?' Is a pipe from 1900 authentic? How old does it have to be, in order to not be a 'reproduction'?
I have an opportunity to buy a Catlinite Pipe, no provenance at all: if owner allows photographs, I will post some close-ups here before purchase..
Any links to Catlinite Pipe evaluation is much appreciated.
Obviously, modern tool marks is a give away, as is a clean bowl interior.
But what about exterior patina: is there 'old' patina to look for? Deep, deep red Catlinite color?
What about 'wear' - should there be wear on an old, authentic stone pipe?
And what constitutes 'authentic?' Is a pipe from 1900 authentic? How old does it have to be, in order to not be a 'reproduction'?
I have an opportunity to buy a Catlinite Pipe, no provenance at all: if owner allows photographs, I will post some close-ups here before purchase..
Any links to Catlinite Pipe evaluation is much appreciated.
Comment