Authentic or replica?

[Grandchamp]

Lost lake replica or legit point?

[JoshinMO]

Either a really nice Authentic or a really nice Faked Replica. More pics including opposite side would help. Nice looking point either way.

[JoshinMO]

Ebay, Flea market or what?

[Grandchamp]

Online yard sale on fb. That's on pic I got let me try to get more

[JoshinMO]

You probably,, got a screaming deal!

[rmartin]

Hard call from your pic. The patina around the 4 inch mark does look kind of funny. Where was it supposedly found?

[rockdigger]

Does not look like a lost lake to me. Maybe a smith. Doesn't look good though but I'm no expert. Still a nice point though. Thanks.

[rmartin]

rockdigger wrote:

Does not look like a lost lake to me. Maybe a smith. Doesn't look fake though but I'm no expert. Still a nice point though. Thanks.

  I agree, good or bad its no Lost Lake.

[Grandchamp]

I didn't buy it haven't even seen it in person but its priced at 200$ they haven't got back to me on location found

[Grandchamp]

Gotta be a fake I'm passing on it. To many shady folks out there the only way I know it's real is if I find it or someone I'm with finds it lol. Just thought it was a lost lake and I know a lost lake that size in that condition was worth ten times their asking price easily.

[Hoss]

Not a Lost Lake point. Looks shady to me too. do they follow AACA rules? Money back guarantee?

[JR]

If its to good to be true....

[johnr]

Hi Definitely a Smith but also definitely modern,  the primary and secondary chipping wrong for a Smith.

[CoachG]

johnr wrote:

Hi Definitely a Smith but also definitely modern,  the primary and secondary chipping wrong for a Smith.

  Ditto

[Speedmaster]

Looks like a cast to me... :huh: